The Wheeler Marketing Model for PSFs
Nearly 40 years' experience advising professional services firms on all aspects of marketing has led us to identify seven processes which are critical to marketing & BD success.
Key marketing and business development processes for PSFs
Understanding the market
Marketing planning
BD
Marketing key clients
Winning new business
Building the brand
Internal marketing
Measuring results
Understanding the market
The fundamental tenet of marketing is "know your market", yet few PSFs do. Most get by on the basis of partners' gut feel, anecdotal market intelligence and unreliable directories.
As a result, firms often have a very sketchy and inaccurate knowledge of:
The demand for their services, how this is changing, and why
Clients' views of the firm and its services
The wider market's perception of the firm, including its awareness and reputation among decision-makers
Competitor activity, including new market entrants
The effectiveness of the firm's marketing and BD activities relative to those of its major competitors
Other factors such as service innovation, the impact of AI, the role of procurement, changing pricing methods, etc.
-
At Wheeler Associates, we provide a range of services to help firms to better understand the markets in which they operate, including:
Market segmentation analysis to group clients and targets according to needs/characteristics
Market perception surveys
Client surveys
Director, company and sector profiles
Competitor analysis
Market assessment surveys to identify users' changing needs
Marketing planning
Planning is important to maintain focus, avoid flitting from initiative to initiative, and to remind oneself that marketing has to be sustained over the long term. Budgets are needed to keep a check on spending.
Too many partners think that marketing and BD can be turned on and off like a tap: "off" when they are busy and "on" when they are quiet and need to generate some work. Of course, the lead time involved in nurturing a relationship with a decision-maker from inception to the point where you receive an instruction is often very long - measured in months and years, rather than days and weeks - so sustained, unbroken relationship building is required to win new business in a consistent fashion. Take your eye off the ball by neglecting a contact during a busy period and one of your competitors will nip in and steal an instruction from under your nose, often without you being aware of it. Managing all this requires a plan of action.
-
At Wheeler Associates, we provide a range of services to help firms to become more effective at managing and growing their key clients, including:
Client base analysis and segmentation
Designing and implementing key account management (KAM) programmes for firms
Working with partners to understand their clients' needs, assemble client service teams, devise client service plans through our Key Client Workshops, and to monitor the effective implementation of these plans
Undertaking client feedback, including independent client service reviews, post-transaction reviews and client satisfaction surveys
Coaching partners to become effective Client Relationship Partners
Winning new business
There is no getting away from the fact that the success of any firm is dependent on the business development skills of its partners. This is more crucial now than ever before. In the past, when work was plentiful, firms could carry a large proportion of their partners who didn't have such skills. These firms relied instead on the work coming to them and the endeavours of a few 'rainmakers'.
Now that work is much scarcer, firms should be investing in business development skills training and coaching for their partners (and other senior work-winners). After bringing their client development skills up to scratch, partners need to gain an appreciation of the 'sales' process for professional services: target → contact → prospect → client. They need to understand how they move along this continuum from target to client; how they use marketing to facilitate this; and, why the best strategy entails building a relationship of trust with a decision-maker, understanding their needs, explaining your capabilities, and waiting for them to buy from you. Now is not the time for aggressive sales tactics, as these are doomed to failure.
As clients look to get the best deal from their advisers, competitive tendering for work is a fact of life for many professionals. In most instances, the chance to pitch against other firms for a piece of work or a place on a panel is the last stage in the new business cycle, with the firm's partners having spent months, or even years, cultivating key contacts at the prospective client, identifying their needs, and positioning the firm as a potential provider of advice.
Unfortunately, all too often, this hard work is wasted and the pitch is lost because the firm fails to get its act together: everything is left to the last minute leaving insufficient time to prepare properly; the firm lacks a real understanding of the prospective client's needs; the firm's pitch 'team' fails to act as a team; and, most crucially, the firm fails to identify and/or communicate a winning proposition.
-
At Wheeler Associates, we provide a range of services to help firms to be more effective at winning new business, including:
Devising targeting and sales programmes for firms
Assisting firms to monitor their sales pipeline
Auditing a firm's pitch process to recommend improvements or establishing a pitch process for the first time
Assisting teams with individual tenders and new business presentations
Conducting pitch debriefs with clients and feeding back to pitch teams
Sales, pitching and new business presentation training and coaching for partners and other senior work-winners
Managing key clients
The number one rule of marketing is to do a great job for your existing clients. This is especially true in today's difficult economic climate where there are fewer new business opportunities. Satisfied clients will give your firm repeat business and recommend you to others.
One of the biggest issues facing professional services firms today is how to maximise the flow of work opportunities from across the firm's client base. As firms have grown larger, extending both the range of services that they offer and their geographical coverage, many have lost the ability to effectively manage and develop relationships with their most important clients.
This problem manifests itself in many ways, including:
Greater focus on winning new clients than on developing existing ones
Client ownership issues: "my client" vs. "the firm's client"
Focus on today's transaction rather than building long term relationships
Insufficient understanding of the client's business and the industry in which it operates
Provision of a reactive rather than a proactive service
Little financial incentive for partners to cross-sell
Multiple points of client contact, leading to a lack of coordination in the delivery of services
Little objective feedback on clients' satisfaction with the firm's services
-
At Wheeler Associates, we provide a range of services to help firms to become more effective at managing and growing their key clients, including:
Client base analysis and segmentation
Designing and implementing key account management (KAM) programmes for firms
Working with partners to understand their clients' needs, assemble client service teams, devise client service plans through our Key Client Workshops, and to monitor the effective implementation of these plans
Undertaking client feedback, including independent client service reviews, post-transaction reviews and client satisfaction surveys
Coaching partners to become effective Client Relationship Partners
Building the brand
The 'science' of branding has been most fully developed in B2C (business-to-consumer) markets and revolves very heavily around advertising. Apple, the world's most valuable brand, is supported by annual global advertising of more than $2 billion. In professional services, branding is less well understood. Many agencies have attempted to apply their B2C branding experience in the sector, often with disastrous consequences because they do not fully understand how clients purchase services from and interact with their business advisers.
A professional services brand has three components:
-
An effective brand is one built around a clear, differentiated proposition. In professional services this equates to an identification of the types of clients that are going to be targeted, in which markets, with which services, and the ways in which these services are to be packaged, priced, promoted and delivered.
-
In the service sector, the brand experience is heavily dependent on the interactions between the organisation's employees and its customers. In professional services, these interactions are even more important, with the brand image that a firm builds in the market being the aggregated result of all the experiences that clients, targets and opinion formers have when they interact with the firm's staff, from partners at one end to receptionists at the other. Rude or arrogant behaviour and sloppy or negligent advice from just a few people can easily damage a firm's reputation and hence its brand.
So, a firm must think very carefully about the sorts of individuals that it wishes to employ and what behaviour traits it expects from these, as the resulting culture will either underpin or undermine the brand. For this reason, recruitment, training and career development are very important for a professional services firm and the success of its brand.
-
The final element of the brand is the firm's visual identity which comprises its name, logo, strapline, and other components associated with its visual communications including fonts, colors, and graphic elements. It also includes the style and production values of its website, advertising and other promotional activities, as well as the design and feel of its offices and reception areas. In a professional services firm, all of these have to be aligned with the 'positioning' and 'behaviour' for the brand to work effectively.
In the past, many professional services firms have attempted to rebrand by just changing their image, usually by changing their logo and corporate design styles, and of course this does nothing to enhance the brand or the fortunes of the business, as fundamentally there is no change to the brand offering.
Firms wishing to manage their brands effectively need to understand how these three elements work together. Unlike in B2C markets where 'image' plays an important part in promoting the 'brand promise', in professional services markets it is the least important of the three elements. Lack of recognition of this fact is often the reason why professional services firm rebrands fail to deliver the hoped-for benefits.
-
At Wheeler Associates, we provide a range of services to help firms to define, build and monitor their brands, including:
Helping firms to identify and articulate a brand proposition
Advising firms how the behavioural changes needed to support their brand can be achieved
Working with our strategic partners to implement a new visual identity for a firm
Advising which relationship marketing tactics are the most cost effective for brand building in the professional services sector
Helping firms to devise and implement Thought Leadership campaigns, the most powerful brand building tactic for PSFs
Conducting brand awareness and brand tracking studies
Internal marketing
For larger firms, the biggest source of new business is the firm's existing client and contact base. Capturing these cross-selling opportunities will be helped greatly by a key client programme and a remuneration system which rewards partners for introducing their clients to other departments within the firm. It is also important that partners understand what their colleagues do and how they add value to a client's business, as this will help them to identify cross-selling opportunities.
It is a well proven fact that staff are more motivated and committed to an organisation if they understand its goals and plans and can see how they are to contribute towards these. Partnerships are notoriously secretive organisations where the majority of partners are often as much in the dark as the rest of the staff. The benefits of a 'one firm' culture can only be achieved if there is open communication and this needs to start at the top.
-
At Wheeler Associates, we provide a range of services to help firms to be more effective at internal marketing, including:
Conducting partner and staff engagement surveys to assess the blockages to internal communications and marketing
Devising an internal communications/marketing strategy for the firm
Advising senior management on the most appropriate internal marketing/communications tools and systems
Measuring results
The current economic climate and a consequent desire to reduce costs have focused firms' attention on the return that they derive from their marketing like never before. Finding ways to measure return on marketing investment (ROMI) is probably the hottest topic in town, alongside the uses for AI in marketing.
For too long, marketers in PSFs have gotten away with justifying their existence based on 'woolly' measures of success: "it's improved our profile"; "lots of people turned up to the seminar"; or, my favourite, "we generated X square inches of coverage from this PR initiative equivalent to £Y of free advertising", the old AVE (Advertising Value Equivalency) argument.
Firms need to be much more focused on those marketing and BD activities which directly generate revenue. For starters, only undertake those relationship marketing activities which are proven to be the most effective for lead generation, including writing articles, speaking at seminars and conferences, publishing thought leadership reports and technical updates, and networking at industry events. Of course, all of these need to be followed up with an effective sales effort to be successful.
Firms need to put a range of metrics in place to measure the results of their marketing including: client satisfaction scores; proposals success rates; awareness levels among decision-makers; etc. In addition, ROMI should be measured using the formula [(Value of New Work - Investment) / Investment] x 100, where 'Investment' is both the cash and time invested in the marketing/BD activity.
-
At Wheeler Associates, we provide a range of services to help firms to measure the results of their marketing, including:
Helping firms to identify those marketing and BD activities which are best at generating revenue
Establishing appropriate marketing metrics for a firm, along with systems for measuring these
Auditing firms' ROMI and benchmarking against competitor firms
Let’s Work Together
If yours is a large or medium-sized professional services firm looking to grow its key clients or win new ones we should talk. With more than 30 years’ marketing & BD experience in the sector we have already helped more than 100 firms globally.